Is Everything Really Your Fault? A Psychologist Explains How to Tell

This blog is based upon my podcast episode Feel Guilty all the Time? You're Taking Too Much Pie.

Most people think about responsibility in black and white. Either it's your fault or it isn't, either you caused it or you didn't, and whoever caused it gets to carry the whole thing.

In my therapy room, that kind of thinking causes an enormous amount of unnecessary suffering, because most outcomes are not the product of one person's actions. They're the product of multiple people, multiple decisions, and multiple circumstances all interacting over time.

Flattening that into a single question of whose fault it is doesn't get you to the truth. It gets you to a story, and usually a very unhelpful one.

There's a better framework. It comes from CBT, I use it constantly in my work with clients, and it's called the responsibility pie.

What the Responsibility Pie Is and How It Works

The idea is this: you imagine the entire situation as a pie. The whole pie represents 100% of what contributed to the outcome, and every person, every decision, every contributing factor gets a slice proportionate to their actual role in what happened.

Your job is to find your slice accurately. Not generously, not minimally. Accurately.

Lets look at an example. A nurse makes a small dosage error and a patient dies. On the surface it looks straightforward — she made the error, so it's her fault.

But when you map it onto the pie, the picture shifts considerably. The medication chart hadn't been updated properly by other staff. The hospital was chronically understaffed and everyone was stretched beyond what's reasonable. Systems for double-checking doses were poor. She was interrupted multiple times while preparing the medication and lost track.

By the time you've accounted for all of that, her slice is considerably smaller than the whole pie. Her error was the final link in the chain, but it was not the only link, and pretending otherwise helps nobody including her.

She still owns her slice fully and without excuses. Her slice is just not 100%.

One more thing worth knowing before you start dividing: sometimes your slice is actually zero. Your actions didn't cause or contribute to the outcome in any legitimate way, and the guilt you're feeling isn't a reliable signal that you're at fault.

Feeling guilty and being guilty are not the same thing. You can feel guilty and have zero responsibility. You can also feel zero guilt and be totally responsible.

The People Carrying Pie That Was Never Theirs

The pattern I encounter most often in trauma therapy is not people dodging responsibility. It's people drowning in it, carrying slices that were never theirs for so long that it hasn't once occurred to them that they're allowed to put them down.

If you grew up in an environment where responsibility was placed on you repeatedly, unfairly, and without warrant, that becomes your template for how accountability works. Someone handed you the whole pie when you were a child, and you took it because that's what you learned to do.

Children don't question whether the pie is theirs, and of course they don't — they shouldn't have to. So they carry it, and they keep carrying it, long into adulthood.

When one person in a relationship consistently refuses their slice, someone else absorbs it, because it has to go somewhere. Without a framework to understand what's happening, you naturally assume it must be yours. Over time that assumption stops feeling like an assumption and starts feeling like a fact. Maybe it really is all my fault. Maybe I really am the problem.

That's not a reflection of reality. That's what happens when you've been served too much pie for too long.

How to Actually Use This

When responsibility feels murky, when guilt is chronic, when someone is insisting that something is entirely your fault, or when you genuinely can't work out how much belongs to you, map the pie.

Image you have a big, apple pie in front of you.

Write down every factor that contributed to the outcome. Stick to real causal factors rather than emotional ones (ask yourself whether a judge would consider each one a legitimate contributing factor).

Give each factor a percentage that's going to turn into their % of pie (aka, how big their slice is).

If you do have a slice, own it fully. Acknowledge it, apologise where that's called for, and do what you can to repair it. A smaller slice doesn't mean you skip it. But once you've owned your actual slice, the rest is not yours to carry, and you're allowed to put it down.

Most importantly, don't take pie that isn't yours.

This post is adapted from Episode 4 of The Trauma Nerd Podcast.

You can listen wherever you get your podcasts, or head to helenbillows.com to find the episode.

If you'd like to stay up to date with my new content, sign up to my newsletter.